Skip to main content

Table 1 A summary of single-gene expression studies performed on developing butterfly wings, indicating whether notable differences in domains of expression have been described in butterflies relative to D. melanogaster

From: Conservation and flexibility in the gene regulatory landscape of heliconiine butterfly wings

Gene

Species

Any novel domains?

References

Ultrabithorax

J. coenia

 

[63, 64]

apterous

J. coenia, B. anynana

Localized reduction in expression associated with ventralization of pattern

[9, 47]

engrailed/invected

J. coenia

Eyespot associated

[9]

 

P. rapae, B. anynana, Saturnia pavonia, Antheraea polyphemus

 

[42]

scalloped

J. coenia

 

[9]

wingless

V. cardui, A. vanillae, J. coenia, Battus philenor, B. mori, M. sexta, Z. morio, B. anynana, P. rapae

Expressed in association with basal and marginal pattern elements

[35, 42, 44]

cut

V. cardui, A. vanillae, J. coenia, Battus philenor, B. mori, M. sexta, Z. morio

 

[35]

hedgehog

J. coenia, B. anynana

Eyespot associated

[26]

cubitus interruptus

J. coenia, B. anynana

Eyespot associated

[26]

patched

J. coenia, B. anynana

Eyespot associated

[26]

achaete-scute

J. coenia

 

[14]

Notch

H. erato, H. melpomene, A. vanillae P. rapae, M. sexta, V. cardui, J. coenia, B. anynana

 

[49, 51]

Optix

Heliconius spp, J. coenia, V. cardui,

Butterfly specific, in association with specific scale types

[36, 50]

WntA

Heliconius spp, Limenitis arthemis, A. vanillae, J. coenia, Danaus plexippus

Butterfly specific, in association with specific pattern elements

[15, 40, 41]

doublesex

Papilio, B. anynana

 

[5, 31]

aristaless1 & aristaless2

J. coenia, Limenitis arthemis, Spodoptera ornithogalli, Ephestia kuehniella

Wing pattern associated, including Discalis II elements

[39]

Distal-less

H. erato, H. melpomene, A. vanillae P. rapae, M. sexta, V. cardui, J. coenia, B. anynana, Saturnia pavonia, Antheraea polyphemus

Dynamic eyespot-associated expression

[6, 9, 51]

spalt major

V. cardui, P. rapae, P. oleracea, Colias philodice, C. eurytheme, B. anynana

Eyespot associated

[42, 57, 67]

decapentaplegic

J coenia, B. anynana

Parallel to veins, in addition to A-P

[9, 11]

Ecdysone receptor

J coenia

Eyespot associated

[28]

pSmad

B. anynana, P. rapae

Eyespot associated

[42]

Antennapedia

B. anynana, Heteropsis iboina, Pararge aegeria and Melanargia galathea, Lasiommata megera, J. coenia, M. cinxia, Inachis io, Caligo memnon

Eyespot associated

[54]

cortex

H. melpomene, H. numata

Butterfly specific, pattern associated

[43]

armadillo

B. anynana

 

[11]

BarH1

Colias

Butterfly specific, pigment associated

[65]

  1. Many of the genes listed, in addition to having domains of expression that are homologous to those found in D. melanogaster, are also expressed in association with eyespots