Research | Open | Published:
Evidence of a largely staminal origin for the Jaltomata calliantha (Solanaceae) floral corona
EvoDevovolume 10, Article number: 9 (2019)
Understanding the evolution of novel features requires homology assessments at different levels of biological organization. In flowering plants, floral coronas that play various roles in plant–pollinator interactions have evolved multiple times independently, but are highly variable in their final position and overall morphology. Coronas of the Solanaceae species Jaltomata calliantha are found between the corolla and stamens, adjacent to the gynoecium, and form cups that house copious amounts of their characteristic blood red nectar. To test the hypothesis that J. calliantha coronas evolved as an outgrowth of stamens and therefore have staminal identity, we assessed their development, floral organ identity gene expression, and cellular morphology.
Jaltomata calliantha coronas emerge after the initiation of all conventional floral organs on the abaxial side of the proximally modified stamens and then expand medially and laterally to form nectar cups. Overlapping expression of the B-class organ identity genes JcAPETALA3 and both JcPISTILLATA/GLOBOSA orthologs (JcGLO1 and JcGLO2), and the C-class-like gene JcAGAMOUS1-like, unites the stamens and corona. Epidermal cell shape also connects the adaxial surface of coronas and petals, and the stamen base, with remaining floral organs showing divergent cell types.
Our data, based on multiple lines of evidence, support a largely staminal origin for J. calliantha coronas. However, since slightly enlarged stamen bases are found in Jaltomata species that lack coronas, and J. calliantha stamen bases share cell types with petals, we hypothesize that stamen bases recruited part of the petal identity program prior to fully expanding into a corona.
The evolution of novel structures—such as leaves, limbs, and flowers—has occurred countless times across the tree of life [1,2,3]. However, while such structures appear novel at the morphological and/or functional level, they often emerge from the rewiring or redeployment of ancient developmental genetic pathways, resulting in complex homology relationships at different levels of organization [4, 5]. Oral teeth of jawed vertebrates, for example, are known to be shaped by a deeply conserved gene regulatory network (GRN) that is shared with skin denticles. Despite this, teeth emerge from epithelial cells associated with taste bud development, suggesting that the latter uniquely coopted the denticle GRN . Such a hierarchical assessment of homology , taking multiple lines of evidence into account, is the key to understanding the evolution of novelty and ultimately of how the diversity of life originated.
In many angiosperms, several such morphological novelties are found within flowers that have ambiguous relationships to conventional floral organs, including crown-like outgrowths often referred to as coronas. In daffodils (Narcissus sp., Amaryllidaceae), the corona arises between the stamen and the inner tepal whorl and superficially resembles petals in terms of shape and pigmentation. Despite this, expression of floral organ identity MADS-box genes suggests a strong affinity between coronas and stamens, whereas developmental analyses suggest positional origins from the underlying hypanthium . Coronas have also been described from several other, distantly related taxa [8, 9]. This includes the remarkable diversity of coronas in the genus Passiflora (passionflowers; Passifloraceae), which range in form from small, inconspicuous structures to organs having stunningly complex combinations of colors, patterns, and appendages , and those that are derived within the Solanaceae genus Jaltomata. Despite their independent origins, MADS-box gene expression in most organs of Passiflora coronas is similar to that in daffodil coronas, again suggesting cooption of a stamen identity program into this novel structure [7, 10]. The extent to which this molecular cooption can be generalized to other coronas that are developmentally and morphologically distinct, including those within Jaltomata, is still a matter of debate.
The use of MADS-box gene expression as one source of data with which to evaluate homology is based on the largely conserved ABC model of floral organ identity specification (but see  for divergence of A-class function), whereby the A-class genes APETALA1/SQUAMOSA (AP1/SQUA) and APETALA2/LIPLESS1/2 (AP2/LIP1/LIP2) specify sepal identity, A- and the B-class genes APETALA3/DEFICIENS (euAP3/DEF) and PISTILLATA/GLOBOSA (PI/GLO) specify petal identity, B- and the C-class gene AGAMOUS/PLENA (AG/PLE) specify stamen identity, and the C-class gene alone specifies carpel identity . Of these five genes, all but AP2 are members of the MADS-box family of transcription factors. Although the initial ABC model was defined based on work in Arabidopsis thaliana (Brassicaceae) and Antirrhinum majus (Plantaginaceae), similar expression patterns and functions have been assigned to most homeotic gene orthologs of the Solanaceae species petunia (Petunia × hybrida) and tomato (Solanum lycopersicum) (reviewed in [13, 14]). One exception is the AP1/SQUA ortholog that has been lost from the petunia genome , although the tomato AP1/SQUA-like gene MACROCALYX (MC) has been found to affect sepal size, but not identity . The petunia AP2/LIP1/LIP2-like gene PhAP2A is expressed most strongly as expected in the first and second whorls, whereas the euAP3/DEF-like gene PhDEF (also known as GREEN PETAL [GP] and PMADS1) and PI/GLO-like genes PhGLO1 (also known as (FLORAL BINDING PROTEIN [FBP1]) and PhGLO2 (also known as PMADS2 and FBP3) are expressed most strongly in the second and third whorls where they affect the identify of petals and stamens . The duplicated AG-like genes pMADS3 and FBP6 are similarly expressed in a conserved manner within the third and fourth whorls [14, 18]. Taken together, these and further data from tomato [19, 20] predict that expression and function of the B-, C-, and at least the AP2-like A-class floral homeotic gene orthologs will be conserved in Jaltomata.
In addition to the A, B, and C floral homeotic genes, two additional classes of MADS-box transcription factors have been implicated in floral organ identity. The D-class genes SEEDSTICK (STK) in A. thaliana, TAGL11 in tomato , and FBP7/FBP11 in petunia are all expressed strongly in ovaries, with mutations in these genes causing ovary to style/stigma homeotic transformations in at least A. thaliana and petunia [22, 23]. In tomato, TAGL11 is additionally expressed in the tapetum of anthers , but the functional significance of this has yet to be determined. In contrast to D-class genes, E-class gene products in eudicots largely stabilize homo- and heterodimers of A, B, C, and D proteins, thus forming organ-specific quartets that regulate the downstream transcription of genes involved in floral organ patterning (reviewed in ). In A. thaliana, three out of the four E-class genes (SEPALLATA1, SEP2, SEP3, and SEP4) need to be mutated in order to see the strong homeotic phenotype of all floral organs converted to sepals [25, 26], whereas cosuppression of petunia E-class genes FBP2 and FBP5 in petals, stamens, and carpels causes a similar phenotype .
Jaltomata coronas are novel and have been described only in the monophyletic Modillonia section, comprised of sister species J. calliantha, J. quipuscoae, and J. aspera [28, 29]. The lack of a corona in the rest of Jaltomata, as well as the Solanum outgroup, indicates that it is a derived trait that evolved only once in the genus . Unlike the previously described coronas of daffodils and Passiflora, coronas of campanulate J. calliantha flowers, as well as those of the other species within the Modillonia, take the form of cups that fill with vivid red nectar that appears to act as an attractant and reward for hummingbird pollinators [30, 31]. A bowl of tissue forms between each of the five stamens, producing five cups that each appear to radiate from the base of the filament and surround the superior gynoecium . Based on this late-stage positional information, the Jaltomata corona might best be interpreted as an outgrowth of stamens, or as stemming as unique primordia from the underlying receptacle.
In this study, we test the hypothesis that derived J. calliantha coronas evolved from recruitment of the stamen organ identity protein complex (PI/GLO, AP3/DEF, AG/PLE, and SEP3/FBP2/FBP5-like) and assess the developmental and cellular origins of these novel structures. We find that positional developmental information, cell micromorphology, and patterns of gene expression support a predominantly staminal identity of coronas, consistent with outgrowth of the corona tissues from the abaxial margins of stamen bases.
Plant growth and tissue collection
Several J. calliantha plants were grown to reproductive phase in an 18–21 °C controlled greenhouse at the University of Vermont under 14-h light conditions with weekly fertilization. Three to five biological replicates of leaves, whole flower buds, and dissected floral tissues were then collected in RNA later (Thermo Fisher Scientific, Waltham, MA, USA), fixed in FAA (3.7% formaldehyde, 50% alcohol, 5% glacial acetic acid), or snap-frozen in liquid nitrogen for downstream analysis.
Fresh flowers of J. calliantha at different developmental stages were imaged using a Leica MZ8 stereoscope. To increase the resolution of cell morphology, FAA-fixed tissues were taken through an alcohol series to 100% ethanol at room temperature, and either critical point dried, sputter-coated with argon, and imaged with a JEOL6060 scanning electron microscope, or stained with 1% Toluidine blue and imaged using a Leica LED microscope.
RNA extraction and cDNA synthesis
RNA was extracted from each tissue sample using TRI Reagent (Thermo Fisher Scientific, Waltham, MA), and contaminating DNA was removed using the TURBO DNase kit (Thermo Fisher Scientific, Waltham, MA, USA), both according to the manufacturer’s instructions. Samples included leaves, dissected sepals, petals, corona, stamens, and gynoecium from mature flowers, as well as dissected sepals, petals, stamens, and gynoecium from pre-corona emergence buds. RNA concentration was estimated using a Quantus Fluorometer (Promega), and 500 ng of each sample was added to iScript cDNA Synthesis kit (BIO-RAD, Portland, ME, USA) half (10 µl) reactions to generate cDNA. Each 10-µl reaction was then diluted 1:10 in water to produce a working solution for PCR.
We used a previously assembled and annotated J. calliantha transcriptome dataset , consisting of RNA from both vegetative and reproductive stages of growth, to find putative MADS-box genes belonging to the AP1/FUL (A-class), PI/AP3 (B-class), AG (C-class), AGL11 (D-class), and SEPALLATA (SEP) (E-class) clades [24, 33]. Nucleotide sequences for each putative homeotic gene homolog were then aligned with A-, B-, C-, D-, and E-class MIKC MADS-box genes downloaded from Phytozome 12 (http://phytozome.jgi.doe.gov/pz/portal/html) or the Sol Genomics Network (https://solgenomics.net) from A. thaliana, petunia, and Aquilegia sp. using MAFFT , with fine-tuning by eye in Mesquite v3.5.1 . The final alignment was submitted to MrBayes v3.2.6 in XSEDE through the CIPRES portal v3.3 for Bayesian phylogenetic analysis [36, 37], using default parameters, except that each of the two runs comprised 10 million iterations. The majority-rule consensus tree was visualized in FigTree v1.4.3 (tree.bio.ed.ac.uk/software/figtree) using the AP1/FUL clade as an outgroup.
Quantitative (q) PCR
Primers were designed for representative A-, B-, C-, and E-class gene orthologs, and the two housekeeping genes EF1alpha and UBQ5, using Primer3 version 4.1.0  (Table 1). Primer pair efficiencies were determined using a dilution series of pooled J. calliantha cDNAs in 20 µl iTaq Universal SYBR Green (BIO-RAD, Portland, ME, USA) reactions. Each reaction was run in triplicate on a StepOne real-time PCR machine (Thermo Fisher Scientific, Waltham, MA, USA) with 60 °C annealing and otherwise recommended conditions. Only primer pairs amplifying products with single melt curves and efficiencies between 90 and 110% (Table 1) were used for quantification of gene expression across different replicated J. calliantha tissues according to the delta cT method. cT values were averaged across technical triplicates and corrected for both primer efficiencies and the geomean of the two housekeeping gene values.
Positional information supports a largely staminal origin for the J. calliantha corona
Conventional J. calliantha floral organs (i.e., sepals, petals, stamens, and gynoecia) initiated in four concentric whorls  (Fig. 1a–c), with the corona emerging later in development, following the differentiation of the stamen filaments and anthers (Fig. 1d, e). Corona tissues were first visible as a ridge on the abaxial side of stamens (Fig. 1d) that gradually extended medially across the inter-staminal space (Fig. 1e) to hug the base of the gynoecium and then laterally to fill the emerging gap between the stamens and gynoecium (Fig. 1g–i). The origin of individual corona initials from the abaxial base of each of the five stamens was evidenced by the two-lobed nature of each corona cup (Fig. 1h) at mid-stages of development. However, by late-stage growth, elongation of the corona cup edges was dominated by growth of a proximal ring primordium that emerged from the inter-staminal region, giving rise to five apparently single-lobed structures (Fig. 1i). Simultaneous with extension of the corona was the swelling of stamen bases that later developed numerous long trichomes (Fig. 1d–f). Similar to the corona, the extent of stamen base swelling is unique to section Modillonia, with other members of the genus having either laminar stamen filaments (e.g., J. repandidentata) (Additional file 1: Fig. S1a) or filaments that have only slightly expanded bases (e.g., J. sinuosa) (Additional file 1: Fig. S1c). Although the function of stamen base swelling is unknown, it may diminish leakage of nectar from the corona cups (Fig. 1j–l), especially as mature flowers are typically pendant among branches.
Partial transformation of the stamen base provides a link between petal identity and corona cellular micromorphology
Examination of individual cells within the emerging corona (Fig. 2h) showed similarities with the rounded and raised epidermal cells at the base of the stamens (Fig. 2g) and adaxial petal surface (Fig. 2c), but lacked the trichomes found on both these structures. In contrast, cells on both sides of the sepal (Fig. 2a, b) and abaxial petal (Fig. 2d) were jigsaw-shaped, whereas cells of the anther (Fig. 2e), stamen filament proper (Fig. 2f), and style (Fig. 2i) were flattened and elongated, and those on the ovary surface were small and very round (Fig. 2j). The difference in cell types between the proximal (i.e., stamen base) and distal regions of the stamen filaments is consistent with partial transformation of stamen base identity toward a more petal-like micromorphology, which can then be extended into the stamen–stamen and stamen–carpel boundary regions to form the corona. Supporting this, similarly sized, shaped, and toluidine blue-stained cells were found on outer surface sections of petals, the corona, and stamen bases (Fig. 2k–m). Furthermore, small cells associated with the inner layer of petals and the corona appeared to be rapidly dividing and deeply stained blue (Fig. 2n, o); these cells were not apparent in any sections through the stamens or gynoecia (Fig. 2n–p).
MADS-box gene retention and expression is largely consistent with a conserved ABCDE model in J. calliantha
A Bayesian phylogenetic analysis of putative J. calliantha orthologs to the A-, B-, C-, D-, and E-class MADS-box genes from A. thaliana, petunia, tomato, and the basal eudicot Aquilegia sp. (Ranunculaceae) revealed six strongly supported (posterior probability > 0.9) monophyletic clades containing AP1/SQUA- (A-class), AP3/DEF- (B-class), PI/GLO- (B-class), AG- (C-class), AGL11- (D-class) and SEP-like (E-class) genes as expected based on  (Fig. 3). Single orthologs to the tomato AP1-like A-class gene (LEMADS-MC), and Solanaceae AG-like (tomato TAG1 and petunia PhpMADS3) and SHATTERPROOF1/2 (SHP1/2)-like (tomato TAGL1) C-class genes were found for J. calliantha. Similar to previous analyses, the majority-rule Bayesian phylogeny supported a duplication of AP3/DEF- and PI/GLO-like genes within or at the base of Solanaceae, with J. calliantha having an ortholog of each, i.e., JcGLO1, JcGLO2, JcAP3, and JcTM6. For the E-class SEP-like genes, one J. calliantha gene orthologous to tomato TM29 and petunia FBP5 was revealed, but no orthologs of tomato MADS1, MADS-RIN, or petunia PhFBP2 were inferred, probably due to incomplete sampling. Finally, two AGL11/PhFBP7-like D-class genes (designated JcAGL11-a and JcAGL11-b) were found in the J. calliantha transcriptome (Fig. 3).
Relative expression analyses of the putative B-class genes JcAP3, JcGLO1, and JcGLO2 demonstrated high expression levels in petals and stamens of both 4 mm young buds and post-anthesis flowers, with little to no transcripts detected in leaves, sepals, or carpels (Fig. 4a, b; Additional file 2: Fig. S2a). Thus, expression of JcAP3 and both JcGLO1 and JcGLO2 was fully consistent with the ABCDE model. In contrast, the JcAP3 paralog JcTM6 was expressed in all conventional floral organs, as well as in leaves (Additional file 2: Fig. S2b). In the case of the putative A-class MADS-box gene JcAP1, expression was found in sepals, petals, and carpels, but not leaves or stamens (Fig. 4e). This expression pattern is broader than that found for A-class genes in A. thaliana; however, studies on several other angiosperm eudicots have found AP1-like expression in both the perianth and carpels (reviewed in ). Similar to the AP3/DEF clade genes, the two J. calliantha members of the AG clade showed divergent patterns of expression. Specifically, whereas the SHP1/2-like C-class gene JcAGL1 fit the prediction of discrete expression within the stamens and carpels at different flower stages (Fig. 4d), the actual AG C-class gene ortholog JcAG was unexpectedly expressed in leaves and sepals, and very strongly in 4 mm bud petals (Fig. 4c). On closer inspection of the translated JcAG amino acid sequence, we found a unique 98 bp insertion in the K domain , 75 amino acids upstream of the conserved stop codon, inside which was a premature stop codon that might explain the non-predicted expression domain. Finally, the E-class SEP1/2 ortholog JcTM29 was expressed broadly across conventional organs as has been found for many SEP-like genes, but transcripts were not detected in leaves (Additional file 2: Fig. S2c).
MADS-box gene expression further supports stamen identity for the corona
For genes that showed the predicted expression pattern in conventional organs according to the ABC model, all were expressed to some extent in coronas. Thus, JcGLO1, JcGLO2, and JcAP3 expression linked corona identity with petals or stamens (Additional file 2: Fig. S2a; Fig. 4a, b), whereas JcAGL1 expression linked corona identity with stamens or carpels (Fig. 4d). Using the floral quartet model as a framework to infer the functional consequences of gene expression, and assuming conservation of protein interactions in J. calliantha, the overlap between JcGLO1, JcGLO2, JcAP3, JcAGL1, and at least one JcSEP-like gene (JcTM29) (Additional file 2: Fig. S2c), strongly supports a staminal origin for coronas (Fig. 4f). On the other hand, the fact that JcAGL1 and JcAP1 were both expressed in coronas (Fig. 4d,e), but not stamens, might be important for modification of the stamen identity floral quartet, giving coronas a somewhat unique identity.
A key role for the field of evolutionary developmental biology is to reveal the underlying mechanisms for the evolution of novel features, i.e., phenotypes that emerge with ambiguous homology to traits present in sister lineages and their inferred common ancestor, and to determine the extent to which convergent phenotypes have been affected by modifications to the same tissues, developmental pathways, and genes . A large body of work dissecting the conserved developmental and genetic basis of flower development—i.e., the floral bauplan—provides us with an excellent opportunity for exploring origins of novel organs [12, 41, 42]. Here, we provide evidence supporting that, similar to coronas in daffodils and passionflowers, the J. calliantha corona emerged from the novel recruitment of the stamen identity program. However, variation in the position, specific morphology, and function of these independently derived coronas is probably the result of mixed developmental origins and the differential regulation of specific downstream genes controlled by corona-specific ABCDE protein tetramer complexes.
Evidence for a predominantly staminal origin of the J. calliantha corona
As is the case for many angiosperm coronas [42, 43], development of the J. calliantha corona is not apparent until late stages of floral ontogeny, after the establishment of the four conventional floral organ types . Thus, this type of corona could be alternately interpreted as an elaboration of preexisting floral organs (as in Caryophyllaceae and Dilleniaceae) [8, 44], or as a novel organ developing from the receptacle (e.g., daffodils and passionflowers) either through neoheterochronic reiteration (sensu ) of a single floral organ type or as a late-stage developmental novelty with only partial homology to one or more floral organs [45, 46]. Support for the former hypothesis comes from several lines of evidence, including positional developmental information, cell micromorphology, and patterns of MADS-box gene expression, as well as intermediate morphology in flowers of hybrids between Jaltomata species with and without a corona (Additional file 1: Fig. S1b,c) (J. L. Kostyun, unpub.). Such hybrid flowers did not present coronas; however, they did have large expanded stamen bases that produced small openings between the ovary and the abaxial side of the stamen bases in which nectar pooled—the same position as corona wells in J. calliantha.
Jaltomata calliantha corona initials first emerge from the abaxial base of stamens, after which they merge through both lateral and medial elongation along the receptacle floor. Such a staminal origin for the corona is supported by the similarity in epidermal cell shapes between the stamen base and the corona. However, a similar cell type is also found on the adaxial surface of petals, suggesting that the stamen base, which is distinct from the stamen filament as well as anther locules, might have been partially transformed in identity before or concomitant with the origin of the corona. The observation that both petals and coronas have small rapidly dividing internal cells that are differentially stained with toluidine blue, provides some evidence for partial transformation of staminode coronas to somewhat petal-like structures. Further work using micro-CT scanning to test for shared vasculature between organs could provide another avenue for testing homologies between coronas, stamens, and/or petals .
Expression of BCE genes in the J. calliantha corona is further consistent with its having a predominantly staminal origin. Both JcPI/GLO orthologs (JcGLO1 and JcGLO2) as well as JcAP3 are expressed as typical B-class genes in petals and stamens, and within the corona, whereas JcAGL1 C-class gene transcripts are confined to stamens, carpels, and the corona. An interesting observation was that JcAG does not show the expected expression pattern in stamens and carpels, which is in contrast to its close ortholog pMADS3 in petunia [14, 18], and TAG1 in tomato (Solanum lycopersicum) (Solanaceae) [20, 48]. Rather, JcAG is expressed in leaves, sepals, and petals, and at relatively low levels in coronas. The presence of a premature stop codon within a K-domain insertion might explain this change in expression, and combined with its low expression sheds doubt on its influence on corona morphology. It will, however, be interesting to determine in the future whether JcAG and JcAP1 expression in coronas, but not stamens, affects the floral quartet, and thus the precise identity of the resulting structure. This will require assessment of protein–protein interactions (e.g., by yeast-two-hybrid assays), and gene-silencing or editing approaches in Jaltomata.
Parallelism in the convergent evolution of floral coronas
The expression of ABCDE genes in coronas has previously been determined in a couple of distantly related species, wherein the coronas either emerge as composite structures from the tepals, hypanthium, and androgynophore (Passiflora caerulea) [10, 49] or from the hypanthium alone (Narcissus bulbocodium) . In P. caerulea, the mixed identity of distinct corona parts is reflected by differences in B- and C-class genes. Perhaps surprisingly, the outer radii and palii, and inner operculum and annulus that develop from the tepals and hypanthium express B- and C-class genes, similar to the stamens, whereas the limen that emerges from the androgynophore only expresses the B-class gene relative TM6. Homology based on AP1-like A-class gene expression is somewhat equivocal, with expression throughout all floral organs (including the corona) during early organogenesis, but suggesting a tentative link between the corona and perianth based on late-stage expression . Taken together, the relative position (P. caerulea) and apparent petaloidy (both species) are not necessarily predictive of the underlying genes involved.
A potential basis for the utilization of a stamen identity program, as observed in the coronas of daffodils, passionflowers, and J. calliantha, is consistent with its flexibility in making different types of structures with varied functions . For example, staminodia, which represent clear cases of stamen transformation either inside, outside, or in place of the stamen whorl, are widespread within angiosperms, but in the cases tested, still express B- and C- class genes . In Aquilegia vulgaris (columbine, Ranunculaceae), the molecular model for transformation of fertile stamens to staminodia is the sub- and/or neo-functionalization of duplicated AP3/DEF genes that are differentially expressed in late-stage stamen and staminodia development [7, 50]. A similar mechanism for diversification of staminodia has been invoked based on the duplication and differential loss of PI/GLO genes in Zingiberales . Differential expression of the J. calliantha AG genes JcAG and JcAGL1 might be implicated in morphological differences between coronas and stamens. Testing the generality of subtle changes in the highly conserved, but often redundant (and therefore robust), stamen identity program to affect morphological novelty will require further sampling of diverse taxa, and the use of transgenic tools to better determine gene function.
Ruelens P, Zhang Z, van Mourik H, Maere S, Kaufmann K, Geuten K. The origin of floral organ identity quartets. Plant Cell. 2017;29:229–42.
Stewart TA, Bhat R, Newman SA. The evolutionary origin of digit patterning. EvoDevo. 2017;8:21.
Harrison CJ, Morris JL. The origin and early evolution of vascular plant shoots and leaves. Philos Trans R Soc Lond B Biol Sci. 2018;373:20160496.
Abouheif E. Developmental genetics and homology: a hierarchical approach. Trends Ecol Evol. 1997;12:405–8.
Oakley TH. Furcation and fusion: the phylogenetics of evolutionary novelty. Dev Biol. 2017;431:69–76.
Martin KJ, Rasch LJ, Cooper RL, Metscher BD, Johanson Z, Fraser GJ. Sox2 + progenitors in sharks link taste development with the evolution of regenerative teeth from denticles. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA. 2016;113:14769–74.
Waters MT, Tiley AMM, Kramer EM, Meerow AW, Langdale JA, Scotland RW. The corona of the daffodil Narcissus bulbocodium shares stamen-like identity and is distinct from the orthodox floral whorls. Plant J. 2013;74:615–25.
Endress PK, Matthews ML. Elaborate petals and staminodes in eudicots: diversity, function, and evolution. Org Divers Evol. 2006;6:257–93.
Ronse De Craene LP, Brockington SF. Origin and evolution of petals in angiosperms. Plant Ecol Evol. 2013;146:5–25.
Hemingway CA, Christensen AR, Malcomber ST. B- and C- class gene expression during corona development of the blue passionflower (Passiflora caerulea, Passifloraceae). Am J Bot. 2001;9:923–34.
Litt A. An evaluation of a function: evidence from the APETALA1 and APETALA2 gene lineages. Int J Plant Sci. 2007;168:73–91.
Coen ES, Meyerowitz EM. The war of the whorls: genetic interactions controlling flower development. Nature. 1991;353:31–7.
Rijpkema A, Gerats T, Vandenbussche M. Genetics of floral development in Petunia. Adv Bot Res. 2006;44:238–78.
Heijmans K, Ament K, Rijpkema AS, Zethof J, Wolters-Arts M, Gerats T, Vandenbussche M. Refining the C and D in the petunia ABC. Plant Cell. 2012;24:2305–17.
Litt A, Irish VF. Duplication and diversification in the APETALA1/FRUITFULL floral homeotic lineage: implications for the evolution of floral development. Genetics. 2003;165:821–33.
Vrebalov J, Ruezinsky D, Padmanabhan V, White R, Medrano D, Drake R, Schuch W, Giovannoni J. A MADS-box gene necessary for fruit ripening at the tomato ripening-inhibitor (rin) locus. Science. 2002;296:343–6.
Vandenbussche M, Zethof J, Royaert S, Weterings K, Gerats T. The duplicated B-class heterodimer model: whorl-specific effects and complex genetic interactions in Petunia hybrida flower development. Plant Cell. 2004;16:741–54.
Kapoor M, Tsuda S, Tanaka Y, Mayama T, Okuyama Y, Tshuchimoto S, Takatsuji H. Role of petunia pMADS3 in determination of floral organ and meristem identity, as revealed by its loss of function. Plant J. 2002;32:115–27.
Quinet M, Bataille G, Dobrev PI, Capel C, Gomez P, Capel J, Lutts S, Motyka V, Angosto T, Lozano R. Transcriptional and hormonal regulation of petal and stamen development by STAMENLESS, the tomato (Solanum lycopersicum L.) orthologue to the B-class APETALA3 gene. J Exp Bot. 2014;65:2243–56.
Gimenez E, Castaneda L, Pineda B, Pan I, Moreno V, Angosto T, Lozano R. TOMATO AGAMOUS1 and ARLEQUIN/TOMATO AGAMOUS-LIKE1 MADS-box genes have redundant and divergent functions required for tomato reproductive development. Plant Mol Biol. 2016;91:513–31.
Busi MV, Bustamante C, D’Angelo C, Hidalgo-Cuevas M, Boggio SB, Valle E, Zabaleta E. MADS-box genes expressed during tomato seed and fruit development. Plant Mol Biol. 2003;52:801–15.
Angenent GC, Franken J, Busscher M, van Dijken A, van Went JL, Dons HJM, van Tunen AJ. A novel class of MADS box genes is involved in ovule development in petunia. Plant Cell. 1995;7:1569–82.
Pinyopich A, Ditta GS, Savidge B, Liljegren SJ, Baumann E, Wisman E, Yanofsky MF. Assessing the redundancy of MADS-box genes during carpel and ovule development. Nature. 2003;424:85–8.
Theissen G, Melzer R, Rumpler F. MADS-domain transcription factors and the floral quartet model of flower development: linking plant development and evolution. Development. 2016;143:3259–71.
Pelaz S, Ditta GS, Baumann E, Wisman E, Yanofsky MF. B and C floral organ identity functions require SEPALLATA MADS-box genes. Nature. 2000;405:200–3.
Ditta G, Pinyopich A, Robles P, Pelaz S, Yanofsky MF. The SEP4 gene of Arabidopsis thaliana functions in floral organ and meristem identity. Curr Biol. 2004;14:1935–40.
Ferrario S, Immink RG, Shchennikova A, Busscher-Lange J, Angenent GC. The MADS box gene FBP2 is required for SEPALLATA function in petunia. Plant Cell. 2003;15:914–25.
Leiva González S, Mione T, Yacher L, Silvestre VQ. Modillonia una nueva sección de Jaltomata Schlechtendal (Solanaceae) con una nueva especies del Norte del Perú. Arnaldoa. 2010;17:163–71.
Wu M, Kostyun JL, Hahn MW, Moyle LC. Dissecting the basis of novel trait evolution in a radiation with widespread phylogenetic discordance. Mol Ecol. 2018;27:3301–16.
Leiva González S, Mione T, Yacher L. Las especies de Jaltomata Schltdl. (Solanaceae) con nectar rojo, tres nuevas combinaciones nomenclaturales y un nuevo taxón del noreste de Perú. Arnaldoa. 2016;23:21–98.
Plourd KC, Mione T. Pollination does not affect floral nectar production, and is required for fruit-set by a hummingbird-visited Andean plant species. Phytologia. 2016;98:313–7.
Kostyun JL, Preston JC, Moyle LC. Heterochronic developmental shifts underlie floral diversity within Jaltomata (Solanaceae). EvoDevo. 2017;8:17.
Becker A, Theissen G. The major clades of MADS-box genes and their role in the development and evolution of flowering plants. Mol Phylog Evol. 2003;29:464–89.
Katoh K, Standley DM. MAFFT multiple sequence alignment software version 7: improvements in performance and usability. Mol Biol Evol. 2013;30:772–80.
Maddison WP, Maddison DR. Mesquite: a modular system for evolutionary analysis. 2018; Version 3.5.1. http://www.mesquiteproject.org. Accessed 3 Jan 2019.
Huelsenbeck JP, Ronquist F. MRBAYES: bayesian inference of phylogeny. Bioinformatics. 2001;17:754–5.
Miller MA, Pfeiffer W, Schwartz T. Creating the CIPRES science gateway for inference of large phylogenetic trees. In: Proceedings of the gateway environments workshop (GCE), New Orleans, LA; 2010. pp. 1–8.
Untergasser A, Cutcutache I, Koressaar T, Ye J, Faircloth BC, Remm M, Rozen SG. Primer3—new capabilities and interfaces. Nucleic Acids Res. 2012;40:e115.
Mizukami Y, Huang H, Tudor M, Hu Y, Ma H. Functional domains of the floral regulator AGAMOUS: characterization of the DNA binding domain and analysis of dominant negative mutations. Plant Cell. 1996;8:831–45.
Brakefield PM. Evo-devo and accounting for Darwin’s endless forms. Philos Trans R Soc Lond B Biol Sci. 2011;366:2069–75.
Kramer EM, Holappa L, Gould B, Jaramillo MA, Setnikov D, Santiago PM. Elaboration of B gene function to include the identity of novel floral organs in the lower eudicot Aquilegia. Plant Cell. 2007;19:750–66.
Chanderbali AS, Berger BA, Howarth DG, Soltis PS, Soltis DE. Evolving ideas on the origin and evolution of flowers: new perspectives in the genomic era. Genetics. 2016;202:1255–65.
Sajo MG, Mello-Silva R, Rudall PJ. Homologies of floral structures in Velloziaceae, with particular reference to the corona. Int J Plant Sci. 2010;171:595–606.
Craven LA. Dunlop CR A taxonomic revision of Pachynema (Dilleniaceae). Aust Syst Biol. 1992;5:477–500.
Baum D, Donoghue MJ. Transference of function, heterotopy and the evolution of plant development. In: Cronk QCB, Bateman RM, Hawkins JA, editors. Developmental genetics and plant evolution. London: Taylor and Francis; 2002. p. 52–69.
Rudall PJ. All in a spin: centrifugal organ formation and floral patterning. Curr Opin Plant Biol. 2010;13:108–14.
Dirks-Mulder A, Butot R, van Schaik P, Wijnands JWPM, van den Berg R, Krol L, Doebar S, van Kooperen K, de Boer H, Kramer EM, Smets EF, Vos RA, Vrijdaghs A, Gravendeel B. Exploring the evolutionary origin of floral organs of Erycina pusilla, an emerging orchid model system. BMC Evol Biol. 2017;17:89.
Pnueli L, Hareven D, Rounsley SD, Yanofsky MF, Lifschitz E. Isolation of the tomato AGAMOUS gene TAG1 and analysis of its homeotic role in transgenic plants. Plant Cell. 1994;6:163–73.
Scorza LCT, Hernandes-Lopes J, Melo-de-Pinna GFA, Dornelas MC. Expression patterns of Passiflora edulis APETALA1/FRUITFULL homologues shed light onto tendril and corona identities. EvoDevo. 2017;8:3.
Sharma B, Kramer E. Sub- and neo-functionalization of APETALA3 paralogs have contributed to the evolution of novel floral organ identity in Aquilegia (columbine, Ranunculaceae). New Phytol. 2013;197:949–57.
Piñeyro-Nelson A, Almeida AM, Sass C, Iles WJ, Specht CD. Change of fate and staminodial laminarity as potential agents of flora diversification in the Zingiberales. J Exp Zool B Mol Dev Evol. 2017;328:41–54.
JLK conceived of the project, JLK and JCP planned and designed the research, all authors conducted the experiments, and JR and JCP wrote the manuscript with input from JLK. All authors read and approved the final manuscript.
We thank Michele von Turkovich of the UVM Microscopy Imaging Center for SEM and other instrument training, and the UVM Greenhouse staff for plant care.
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
Availability of data and materials
Seed material was originally obtained from Dr. Thomas Mione at Central Connecticut State University and propagated by JLK in Dr. Leonie Moyle’s laboratory at Indiana University. Raw image data and sequence alignments are available from the authors on request.
Consent for publication
Ethics approval and consent to participate
This work was funded by a UVM Plant Biology Sproston award given to JR.
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.