- Open Access
Convergent evolution of saccate body shapes in nematodes through distinct developmental mechanisms
EvoDevo volume 10, Article number: 5 (2019)
The vast majority of nematode species have vermiform (worm-shaped) body plans throughout post-embryonic development. However, atypical body shapes have evolved multiple times. The plant-parasitic Tylenchomorpha nematode Heterodera glycines hatches as a vermiform infective juvenile. Following infection and the establishment of a feeding site, H. glycines grows disproportionately greater in width than length, developing into a saccate adult. Body size in Caenorhabditis elegans was previously shown to correlate with post-embryonic divisions of laterally positioned stem cell-like ‘seam’ cells and endoreduplication of seam cell epidermal daughters. To test if a similar mechanism produces the unusual body shape of saccate parasitic nematodes, we compared seam cell development and epidermal ploidy levels of H. glycines to C. elegans. To study the evolution of body shape development, we examined seam cell development of four additional Tylenchomorpha species with vermiform or saccate body shapes.
We confirmed the presence of seam cell homologs and their proliferation in H. glycines. This results in the adult female epidermis having approximately 1800 nuclei compared with the 139 nuclei in the primary epidermal syncytium of C. elegans. Similar to C. elegans, we found a significant correlation between H. glycines body volume and the number and ploidy level of epidermal nuclei. While we found that the seam cells also proliferate in the independently evolved saccate nematode Meloidogyne incognita following infection, the division pattern differed substantially from that seen in H. glycines. Interestingly, the close relative of H. glycines, Rotylenchulus reniformis does not undergo extensive seam cell proliferation during its development into a saccate form.
Our data reveal that seam cell proliferation and epidermal nuclear ploidy correlate with growth in H. glycines. Our finding of distinct seam cell division patterns in the independently evolved saccate species M. incognita and H. glycines is suggestive of parallel evolution of saccate forms. The lack of seam cell proliferation in R. reniformis demonstrates that seam cell proliferation and endoreduplication are not strictly required for increased body volume and atypical body shape. We speculate that R. reniformis may serve as an extant transitional model for the evolution of saccate body shape.
How do body shapes evolve? Most nematodes are vermiform (i.e., worm-shaped) throughout post-embryonic development. However, several diverse nematode species develop from vermiform juveniles into saccate adult females. For example, females of the avian parasitic Tetrameridae family have a distended shape . Similarly, the shark-parasitic nematode Phlyctainophora squali develops into a coiled and globose female . Among Tylenchomorpha nematodes, several of the most economically damaging plant-parasitic nematode species develop into saccate-shaped adult females following infection . Heterodera glycines hatches as a vermiform infective second-stage juvenile (J2). Following infection and the establishment of a feeding site, H. glycines females grow disproportionately greater in width than length, developing into saccate-shaped adults. Male H. glycines also initially grows disproportionally in width following infection. During the final juvenile stage (J4), males remodel into vermiform adults.
Not all saccate-shaped nematodes undergo the same sequence of developmental events as H. glycines. The closely related species Rotylenchulus reniformis hatches as a vermiform J2. Interestingly, R. reniformis does not infect following hatching, but rather molts through subsequent vermiform juvenile stages without feeding . Upon molting into a vermiform adult female, R. reniformis infects a host and subsequently develops into a saccate-shaped female.
Based on the current hypothesized phylogeny of nematodes, development into saccate adults among Tylenchomorpha nematodes evolved at least twice (Fig. 1) [5, 6]. Similar to H. glycines, the independently evolved root-knot nematode, Meloidogyne spp. grows from a vermiform J2 into a saccate adult female following infection. Unlike H. glycines, much of the growth in M. incognita occurs prior to the molt into J3, which is quickly followed by the molts into the J4 and adult female without intervening feeding. After molting into the adult, the female resumes feeding and further growth . The mechanisms regulating the development of saccate body shapes in nematodes are unknown.
In the bacterial-feeding nematode Caenorhabditis elegans, the growth of the epidermis is considered a major determinant of body size . Most of the C. elegans epidermis comprises a single large syncytium (hyp7) that grows during post-embryonic development as a succession of nuclei fuse with it . The post-embryonic hyp7 nuclei are daughters of the seam cells, a series of laterally positioned epidermal cells with stem cell-like properties . Newly hatched J1 C. elegans have ten seam cells on each lateral ridge that divide in a stem cell-like pattern before each molt (Fig. 2) . Most seam cell divisions generate an anterior daughter nucleus, which fuses with hyp7, and a posterior daughter seam cell. Following the final molt, the seam cells terminally differentiate and fuse to form a separate syncytium [10, 11].
The evolution of nematode body size was suggested to be due to changes in seam cell proliferation and endoreduplication of nuclei within the epidermal syncytium [8, 12]. However, a recent report demonstrated that a newly isolated Caenorhabditis species evolved increased length due to increased cytoplasmic volume rather than nuclear number or ploidy . We hypothesized that the H. glycines seam cell lineage has undergone extensive evolutionary changes to grow from a vermiform juvenile to a saccate adult female. To understand the evolution of saccate-shaped nematodes, we examined the development of H. glycines as well as the closely related R. reniformis and the independently evolved saccate species M. incognita. As comparisons, we also examined three Tylenchomorpha species that have typical vermiform shapes throughout development.
The number of H. glycines epidermal nuclei increases following infection
Heterodera glycines hatches as a vermiform-shaped infective J2. Following infection, it establishes a multinucleated feeding site and develops into a saccate-shaped adult female in 11–13 days (Fig. 3). To test if the number of epidermal nuclei increases during post-hatch development, we examined DAPI-stained H. glycines at different developmental stages. We found 44 epidermal nuclei in pre-infective H. glycines J2 s (Table 1, Fig. 4a). The number of epidermal nuclei increases approximately 40-fold from the pre-infective J2 to the adult female (Table 1, Fig. 4b). In comparison, the hyp7 epidermal syncytium in C. elegans adult hermaphrodites comprises 139 epidermal nuclei .
H. glycines has seam cell homologs
The C. elegans seam cell divisions contribute to an increase in the total number of nuclei present in the surrounding syncytial epidermis (hyp7) during post-embryonic development . To our knowledge, there are no data on seam cells in H. glycines. The C. elegans seam cells have a distinctive eye-shaped appearance using light microscopy with DIC optics; however, due to the highly refractile optical properties of the pre-infective H. glycines J2 s, we were not able to observe any seam cell-like structures at this stage. We, therefore, used transmission electron microscopy (TEM) to examine pre-infective J2 s. Similar to C. elegans seam cells, we found electron-dense adherens junctions on each lateral side along the length of H. glycines J2 s (Fig. 5) . Within 2 days post-infection, the refractile optical properties of H. glycines are reduced and, using DIC light microscopy, we observed a line of elliptical, smoothly tapered epidermal cells along the lateral epidermis from the nose to tail (Fig. 6a). These epidermal cells are morphologically similar to C. elegans seam cells . Similar to J1 C. elegans, we observed ten seam cells on each side of J2 H. glycines. Specifically, we found three seam cell nuclei in the head (one adjacent to the stylet, one adjacent to the metacarpus, one adjacent to the dorsal esophageal gland). Posteriorly, six seam cells lay along the length of the body and a tenth was found in the tail (Fig. 6a). Thus, using both light microscopy and TEM, we confirmed that H. glycines also has seam cells.
H. glycines seam cells undergo extensive proliferation following infection and subsequent molts
We hypothesized that growth of H. glycines following infection requires proliferation of the seam cells. As H. glycines spends much of its development within the roots of its host, we were unable to follow the cell lineage continuously. As an alternative, we dissected nematodes from the roots at multiple time points following infection and examined the seam cells in both live and DAPI-stained fixed animals. Using DIC optics, we found that following infection the posterior eight seam cells appear in contact with each other (Fig. 6b). Within 3 days following infection, the nine posterior seam cells undergo a symmetrical cell division to produce two seam cells (Figs. 6c, 7a, b). The resulting 18 seam cells undergo divisions (Fig. 7b, c), to produce four epidermal daughter cells (Fig. 7d), oriented dorsoventrally during late J2. By the time of the J2/J3 molt, we observed only elliptical-shaped nuclei (Fig. 7e arrow) along the lateral ridge suggesting an apparent dorsoventral migration of seam daughter nuclei (Fig. 7e). To confirm this migration of seam cell daughter cells from the lateral ridge, we examined the seam cell division and migration in post-infective J2 live animals dissected from the roots (Fig. 8). While plant-parasitic nematodes will not feed following removal from their host, a limited amount of development will occur. Consistent with our DAPI staining, we observed cell divisions along the lateral ridge of four dpi animals (Fig. 8). Examination of subsequent time points showed that the number of cells along the lateral line increases with time (Fig. 8, 4.5 h). As the J2 approaches the J2/J3 molt (Fig. 8, 25 h), dorsoventrally oriented cells migrated dorsoventrally (Fig. 8, 34 h). Together, our DAPI and live animal imaging suggest that proliferation of seam cells and the subsequent dorsoventral migration of daughter cells occur following infection.
Using DAPI staining, we found that the J3/J4 and J4/adult female molts are each associated with a round of seam cell proliferation and subsequent migration of epidermal daughter nuclei away from the lateral ridge (Fig. 9). This molt-associated proliferation is similar to that seen in C. elegans; however, C. elegans seam cells do not divide during the J4/adult molt . In H. glycines, the molts were preceded by an initial proliferation along the lateral ridge and accumulation of daughter cells that was followed by dispersal into the subdorsal and subventral regions (compare Figs. 4b, 8). Interestingly, each subsequent molt appeared to result in the production of more daughter cells.
The proliferation of seam cells during the J3/J4 and J4/adult molts did not occur in a perfectly synchronous pattern within individual nematodes. This asynchrony combined with the difficulties in synchronizing infection made it impossible to quantify the precise number and lineage of daughter nuclei produced by each seam cell at these later time points. We found that H. glycines J3 and J4 females have 544 and 972 epidermal nuclei, respectively (Table 1). Each successive molt resulted in an approximate doubling of epidermal nuclei (Table 1). After the final molt, an average of 1758 epidermal nuclei were evenly distributed in adult females (Table 1 and Fig. 4b). While we cannot be confident in the precise pattern of divisions, our findings suggest a possible lineage model where the number of divisions increases at each successive molt (Fig. 10).
H. glycines has an epidermal organization similar to C. elegans
Most of the post-embryonic C. elegans epidermis comprises a multinucleate syncytium that surrounds the lateral seam cells . To determine if the H. glycines epidermis has a similar organization, we stained post-infective nematodes with the F-actin binding fluorescent probe AlexaFluor phalloidin. In phalloidin-stained animals, we observed bright fluorescence surrounding each nucleus within the lateral seam, but none in the surrounding epidermis suggesting a similar epidermal syncytial organization to C. elegans (Fig. 11a, c). To confirm this observation, we examined post-infective juveniles with TEM and found a cluster of nuclei on the lateral ridge with distinct cell membranes (Fig. 11d). This cluster of seam cells was surrounded by a larger epidermal area with periodic nuclei not interrupted with apparent cell membranes (Fig. 11d). Together, these data suggest that H. glycines seam cells are surrounded by an epidermal syncytium. Recent research showed that the C. elegans derived antibody MH27 labels apical junctions in the Tylenchina nematode Zeldia punctata . Unfortunately, we were not successful in our attempts at staining H. glycines with MH27.
H. glycines male seam cells proliferate less than female seam cells
Similar to J3 females, H. glycines J3 males are sausage-shaped. Using phalloidin, we found that H. glycines male seam cells are also surrounded by a syncytium (Fig. 11b). Interestingly, we found that H. glycines J3 male seam cells proliferate less than in females (Fig. 12a, compared to 9a). Unlike in J3 females, where seam daughter nuclei migrate dorsoventrally, in H. glycines J3 males, they remain in the lateral epidermis (Fig. 12a). By the J3/J4 molt, H. glycines males begin remodeling back to a vermiform where they become coiled within the old cuticle. Due to the coiling of male J4 s (Fig. 12b) and background fluorescence from sperm cells in adult males (Fig. 12c), we were unable to accurately quantify the number of epidermal nuclei. Similarly, in live adult male animals, we were not able to accurately count the number of epidermal nuclei due to the increased refractile nature for live DIC imaging and the tendency of adult male H. glycines to twist along their longitudinal axis.
H. glycines epidermal nuclei are polyploid
Caenorhabditis elegans epidermal nuclei are polyploid  and previous results showed a correlation between body volume and the product of epidermal ploidy level and the number of epidermal nuclei among several bacterial-feeding nematodes . We measured the DNA content of H. glycines epidermal nuclei during the J2/J3 molt and adult females using microdensitometry. To confirm our intensity measurements, we first compared haploid sperm nuclei fluorescent intensity to diploid neuronal nuclei. As expected, we found an approximate doubling of fluorescence between the haploid sperm and diploid neurons (Fig. 13a). Fluorescent intensity was then compared between female neuronal nuclei and epidermal nuclei at the J2/J3 molt and in adult females. We observed a threefold to fourfold increase in fluorescent intensity between diploid neuronal nuclei and epidermal nuclei, suggestive of epidermal polyploidy (7.1C in J2/J3, 7.7C in adult) (Fig. 13a). While there was substantial variation among individuals, overall our data suggest that H. glycines epidermal nuclei are polyploid.
H. glycines number and ploidy level of epidermal nuclei correlate with body size
We conducted a regression analysis to determine if the increasing number of epidermal nuclei and ploidy level at each successive molt correlate with the increasing body size of H. glycines. We found a significant correlation between the product of number and ploidy level of epidermal nuclei and the estimated body volume (R2 = 0.86; P < 0.0001) of H. glycines at different developmental stages (Fig. 13b). Our results demonstrate that the growth of H. glycines from a vermiform J2 to a saccate adult female is associated with extensive proliferation of the seam cells and polyploidy.
Because there was a large difference in the number of epidermal nuclei between H. glycines and previously examined vermiform bacterial feeders , we were curious whether this was due to a clade-wide change in the relationship of epidermal nuclei and ploidy to body size. We, therefore, examined the number and ploidy of epidermal nuclei in vermiform Tylenchomorpha species. Hoplolaimidae (Helicotylenchus sp.) is a sister family to H. glycines Heteroderidae (Fig. 1); however, Helicotylenchus sp. is vermiform throughout post-embryonic development. We observed seam cells along the lateral ridge of Helicotylenchus sp., morphologically similar to H. glycines and C. elegans (Fig. 14a), . We found that J4 female Helicotylenchus sp. contained 194 epidermal nuclei (n = 13) with a mean ploidy of 3.4C (n = 13; number of nuclei = 130). We also examined Aphelenchus avenae, a fungal feeding vermiform Tylenchomorpha (Fig. 1). Again, we observed seam cells along the lateral ridge (Fig. 14b) . In A. avenae J4 females, we found 220 epidermal nuclei (n = 6) and a ploidy of 3.3C (n = 6; number of nuclei = 60). Together, these data suggest that the epidermal proliferation of H. glycines was not due to an earlier evolutionary event leading to a general increase in epidermal nuclei in all Tylenchomorpha.
Divergent division patterns acting on conserved seam cells gave rise to independently evolved saccate body shapes
Saccate body shapes likely evolved multiple times among nematodes (Fig. 1) [5, 6]. To determine if the saccate shape in other nematodes is also correlated with seam cell proliferation, we examined the independently evolved saccate nematode M. incognita (Fig. 1). We hypothesized that despite their independent origins, H. glycines and M. incognita would use a similar pattern of seam cell proliferation to increase the number of epidermal nuclei and ploidy level associated with their increased volumes. To determine if the number and ploidy of epidermal nuclei is associated with an independently derived saccate body form, we examined the young adult females of M. incognita. We counted 598 epidermal nuclei (n = 9) and a mean ploidy level of 4.67C (n = 9, no of nuclei = 90) in M. incognita. Young adult M. incognita females continue to grow even after the final molt, and our preliminary data suggest a corresponding increase in the number of epidermal nuclei; late adult females have 948 epidermal nuclei (n = 2) (Fig. 15). As a closely related vermiform control (Fig. 1), we found that Pratylenchus penetrans J4 females have an average 100 epidermal nuclei (n = 5). Due to background fluorescence in P. penetrans, we were unable to accurately measure the ploidy level in this species. Our results suggest that similar to H. glycines, M. incognita proliferation of epidermal nuclei is associated with a saccate body shape.
Unlike H. glycines, which grows throughout each juvenile stage, much of the growth in Meloidogyne spp. occurs during J2 following infection with very little increase in size occurring during the J3 and J4 stages . We found that J2 M. incognita extracted soon after infection have a line of epidermal cells along the lateral seam morphologically similar to H. glycines and C. elegans seam cells (Fig. 16a) . To further examine the proliferation of epidermal nuclei in M. incognita, we conducted an analysis of DAPI-stained juveniles at successive time points following infection. Following the J2/J3 molt, we did not observe a clustering of nuclei along the lateral ridge as observed during H. glycines. Interestingly, staining with phalloidin revealed putative cell junctions in the subventral and subdorsal quadrants and an unusual pattern of staining along the lateral seam (Fig. 16b). While our time points are insufficient to propose a comprehensive model of epidermal division in M. incognita, the pattern of divisions appears to deviate from H. glycines.
R. reniformis does not use seam cell proliferation to increase body size
Rotylenchulus reniformis is a saccate-shaped nematode and phylogenetically proximal to H. glycines (Fig. 1). Unlike H. glycines, the adult female of R. reniformis is the infective stage and becomes saccate following infection. The mature saccate R. reniformis female is smaller in volume compared with H. glycines. We, therefore, hypothesized that R. reniformis would have an intermediate number of nuclei between H. glycines and Helicotylenchus sp. Similar to H. glycines and C. elegans, we found a line of laterally positioned epidermal nuclei consistent with seam cells (Fig. 17a) . The R. reniformis adult parasitic female has only 50 epidermal nuclei (n = 8) and a ploidy level of 5.2C (n = 8; number of nuclei = 80). We conducted a time-course analysis, but did not observe any epidermal divisions following infection. Rather, we observed that swelling of the body occurred adjacent to and concurrent with the enlarging gonad (Fig. 17b–g). This result suggests that epidermal proliferation is not strictly required for the development of a saccate body shape.
Atypical body shape in nematodes is not strictly associated with the number or ploidy level of epidermal nuclei
We examined the relationship between the body volume and the number and ploidy level of epidermal nuclei across species (H. glycines, M. incognita, R. reniformis, A. avenae, and Helicotylenchus sp.). We found no significant association between the estimated body volume and the product of number and ploidy of epidermal nuclei across species (R2 = 0.22; P = 0.41), (Fig. 18a). This finding, while contradictory to Flemming et al. , is in agreement with recent results showing a large size difference between C. elegans and a newly described Caenorhabditis sp. that does not correlate with changes in epidermal nuclear number or ploidy . To further examine the relationship between body size and epidermal nuclear number/ploidy, we mapped our data from Tylenchomorpha species onto the linear regression model from Flemming et al. . Interestingly, we found H. glycines and R. reniformis lay outside of the 95% prediction interval of their data (Fig. 18b).
Our results suggest that the stem cell-like seam cells are conserved in Tylenchomorpha nematodes. Similar to C. elegans, we found that the lateral ridge of H. glycines comprises elliptical-shaped cells with proliferative capacity. Furthermore, using TEM, we observed characteristic adherens junctions along the lateral ridge. Using light microscopy, we found similar cells in all nematodes examined here. While we did not conduct TEM on other species, an examination of published and unpublished TEM data suggests that adherens junctions along the lateral ridge are also present in Meloidogyne incognita and Pratylenchus penetrans [18, 19]. Seam cells are present in bacterial-feeding nematodes Panagrellus redivivus and Pristionchus pacificus [20, 21]. Similarly, the seam cells were found in a group of diverse bacterial-feeding nematodes . We hypothesize that seam cells are conserved within the crown clades of Chromadoria [5, 6].
We show that epidermal proliferation is extensive in H. glycines. Most C. elegans seam cell divisions lead to the formation of a single hyp7 epidermal nucleus and a posterior seam cell . In contrast, we found that seam cell proliferation in H. glycines leads to increasing numbers of epidermal nuclei daughter cells at each successive molt (Fig. 10). Occasionally, the C. elegans seam lineage leads to the formation of glia or neuronal daughters. For example, the C. elegans seam cell V5 leads to the formation of the post-deirid neurons prior to the L2 molt. Due to the parasitic nature of H. glycines development, we were unable to follow the precise lineage of seam cells; however, we did not observe DAPI-stained nuclei with a neuron-like morphology and a position suggestive of post-deirids.
Our results may suggest that epidermal proliferation and the increase in epidermal ploidy cause the increase in body volume of H. glycines. We found a strong correlation between the product of epidermal nuclear number by ploidy and the body volume. Interestingly, we also found that the marked sexual dimorphism in H. glycines is represented by a different number of epidermal nuclei found during the J3 stage. These results support a possible causative link between epidermal nuclei and body size. The primary control strategy for H. glycines is host resistance. H. glycines females are smaller on resistant varieties than on susceptible varieties . It will be interesting to know if this size difference is due to decreased seam cell proliferation or epidermal ploidy.
A question our data still do not answer is why epidermal proliferation in H. glycines does not simply lead to large vermiform nematodes that grow proportionally in length and width? In C. elegans, the elongation of embryos beyond the twofold stage requires the contraction of body wall muscles . Ablation of C. elegans body wall muscle leads to swelling around the destroyed cells . We recently demonstrated that H. glycines and M. incognita undergo progressive muscle atrophy with the onset of the sedentary life cycle . This atrophy corresponds with the increase in size. We speculate that in H. glycines and M. incognita, the atrophy of body wall muscles following infection prevents the maintenance of a vermiform shape by eliminating the lengthening forces found in other nematodes.
Body size in nematodes was hypothesized to have evolved due to changes in the number and ploidy of epidermal nuclei . Our data do not strictly fit that model. While we found a significant correlation between the product of the number and ploidy of epidermal nuclei and H. glycines body size during post-embryonic development; our H. glycines data lay outside of the 95% prediction interval proposed by Flemming et al. . Indeed, based on the number and ploidy of epidermal nuclei in adult H. glycines females, the Flemming model predicts a body volume 100-fold greater than our experimental measurements. We previously showed that the H. glycines epidermis increases in thickness following infection . Also, post-infective H. glycines secretes exudates from the cuticle that are proposed to originate from the thickened epidermis . Perhaps, rather than increased body volume, the unexpectedly large number of epidermal nuclei and increased ploidy in H. glycines are used to provide increased epidermal thickness and protein synthesis.
Our results suggest that multiple mechanisms may lead to a saccate body shape. Similar to H. glycines, M. incognita undergoes extensive epidermal proliferation and epidermal polyploidy. However, the apparent organization of seam cells differs from that observed in H. glycines. The presence of phalloidin-stained structures similar to seam cell apical junctions in the subventral and subdorsal quadrants of M. incognita in post-infective stages could point to the formation of a separate seam cell pool. This will require further examination using both additional light microscopy and TEM. One obvious caveat to the phalloidin staining is its unspecific nature as a general F-actin probe. The unusual pattern of staining in M. incognita may not indicate apical junctions, but rather other actin-enriched structures. As H. glycines and M. incognita likely evolved saccate morphologies independently, we suggest that this serves as an example of parallel evolution where a similar parasitic environment led to selection for increased proliferation of the seam cells acting through distinct mechanisms.
The evolution from vermiform to saccate nematode may have occurred through an intermediate transitional stage as represented by R. reniformis, which shows no obvious epidermal proliferation following infection. The increase in R. reniformis body volume from vermiform to saccate is substantially smaller than that found in H. glycines. H. glycines produces more offspring than R. reniformis [27, 28], and it is generally accepted that saccate nematodes have a greater reproductive potential than vermiform species. We observed that the swelling of R. reniformis began proximal to the growing gonad. In contrast, the increase in H. glycines body volume far outpaces the development of its gonad (here and ). We speculate that the increased fecundity of saccate nematodes began with the evolution of a larger gonad size similar to R. reniformis. This was followed by proliferation of the epidermis allowing for larger gonads with additional reproductive capacity. This hypothesis will require extensive examination of saccate species from additional clades.
Our data reveal that seam cell development has undergone extensive evolutionary changes from C. elegans and that the number and ploidy of H. glycines epidermal nuclei correlate with growth in size. Interestingly, the change in the number of H. glycines epidermal nuclei and ploidy level does not fit a previously established model of body volume in vermiform species, suggesting that these factors may regulate other aspects of development in the Tylenchomorpha species. Our finding of different seam cell division patterns in the independently evolved saccate species M. incognita and H. glycines provides an example of parallel evolution acting through homologous cells. The number of epidermal nuclei and ploidy level is associated with H. glycines and M. incognita shape changes. However, R. reniformis does not demonstrate extensive seam cell proliferation following infection suggesting distinct mechanisms evolved to produce a similar phenotype from a common ancestor. We hypothesize that R. reniformis may serve as an extant transitional model for the evolution of atypical body shapes.
Materials and methods
Heterodera glycines was isolated from a soybean field in Illinois, USA, and maintained on susceptible soybean (cv. Macon) in the greenhouse. To collect synchronized developmental stages of H. glycines, soybean seeds were germinated in moist paper towels for 3 days. Soybean seedlings were then placed in pluronic gel F-127 with freshly hatched J2 for 24 h . Soybean roots were washed with water to remove nematodes that had not infected roots within 24 h of inoculation. Then, H. glycines-infested roots were planted in sandy loam soil and kept in a growth chamber at 22–24 °C and 12-h light cycle until extraction. After inoculation, the infested roots were grown for 6–7 days to collect J3 s, 8–10 days to collect J4 s, 11–13 days for adult females, and 15 days for adult males . Infested roots were macerated with a hand blender to obtain H. glycines at specific time points. The mixture was poured over stacked 850-, 250-, and 25-μm-pore sieves. The developmental stage and sex of each individual were determined based on overall body size and gonad morphology .
Meloidogyne incognita (gift from Dr. Jason Bond) was originally isolated from soybean and maintained on tomato (cv. Rutgers) in the greenhouse. To collect synchronized developmental stages of M. incognita, two-week-old tomato seedlings were inoculated with freshly hatched J2 s. Tomato seedlings were gently removed from the soil and washed with water to remove nematodes that had not infected roots within 48 h following inoculation. M. incognita-infested roots were then planted in sandy loam soil and kept in a growth chamber at 22–24 °C and a 12-h light cycle until extraction. The nematodes were extracted using a hand blender to collect different developmental time points of post-infective J2 s .
Rotylenchulus reniformis (gift from Dr. Martin Wubben) was maintained in sandy loam soil on soybean (cv. Macon) in the greenhouse. To study the non-parasitic stages, eggs were incubated at 30 °C. Different developmental stages were identified based on their morphology and number of cuticles . R. reniformis parasitic adult females were extracted as described above for H. glycines.
Aphelenchus avenae was originally isolated from the rhizosphere of garlic plants and identified using morphological characters. A. avenae was cultured on 1/8 strength Potato Dextrose Agar (PDA) with the fungus Botrytis cinerea . To collect the synchronized A. avenae eggs, gravid females were incubated in 5% M9 buffer . After 5 h, females were removed, and eggs were incubated at room temperature for approximately 48 h. Hatched J2 s were transferred to 1/8 strength PDA with B. cinerea. Developmental stages were determined based on body size and gonad morphology.
Pratylenchus penetrans (gift from Dr. Terry Niblack) was cultured on corn root explants on Murashige and Skoog (MS) media . Specific developmental stages of P. penetrans were isolated by synchronizing populations from eggs. P. penetrans eggs were extracted as previously described . Freshly hatched J2 s were collected and placed on corn root explants on MS media. To recover different developmental stages, P. penetrans culture plates were flooded with water and animals were handpicked under a dissecting scope. Developmental stages of P. penetrans were determined based on body size and gonad morphology.
Helicotylenchus sp. was isolated from soybeans at the University of Illinois research farm and maintained on soybean (cv. Macon) in sandy loam soil in the greenhouse. J4 molting stage animals were determined based on the presence of a shedding cuticle, body size, and gonad morphology.
Live nematode imaging
Nematodes were mounted on a 4% agarose pad on microscope slides kept at room temperature in a dark humidity chamber when not imaging. Slides were rehydrated as needed. Images were taken every hour for 2 days, using an upright compound microscope with a mechanized stage (Zeiss M2 AxioImager and Zen software). Seam cells were identified based on their location and morphology .
DAPI (4′, 6-diamidino-2-phenylindole) staining
Heterodera glycines was fixed in Carnoy’s fixative (60% ethanol, 30% acetic acid, 10% chloroform) overnight at room temperature [8, 17]. Nematodes were transferred to 75% ethanol and stained with 0.2–0.5 μg/ml of DAPI overnight in the dark at room temperature. Images were taken using a Zeiss M2 AxioImager with differential interference contrast (DIC) and fluorescence optics. In C. elegans, the epidermal nuclei are large and flat, contain large nucleoli and are located in four main cords . The number of epidermal-like nuclei was counted from the metacarpus to anus. The number of epidermal nuclei counted on one side of the animal was doubled to estimate the total number of epidermal nuclei. To estimate the body volume of H. glycines, the length of the animal was measured from head to tail, and the mean diameter was calculated from three separate measurements (close to the head, the middle part of the body, and close to the tail) using FIJI. The volume was then estimated based on the equation for the volume of a cylinder during J2 and J3 and the shape of a sphere in adult females. At least six animals were examined for each developmental stage. The data were log transformed and regression analysis was performed using GraphPad Prism version 7.00 for Windows, GraphPad Software, La Jolla California USA, www.graphpad.com.
The ploidy of H. glycines epidermal nuclei was calculated based on previous methods [8, 17]. DAPI-stained sperm nuclei from adult males were used as a haploid control and included in each experimental session. Fluorescence intensity, exposure time, and all other microscope settings were kept consistent during imaging. The fluorescence level of the epidermal nuclei and sperm nuclei were measured using ImageJ software. The nuclei of interest were marked and their integrated density (fluorescence in the area of the region of interest × the mean fluorescence of the region of interest) was measured. The corrected fluorescence intensity was calculated by subtracting the background fluorescence in eight male animals, eight J2 molting stages animals, five J3 females, and 13 adult females . In each animal, the fluorescence intensity of ten epidermal nuclei and ten neuronal nuclei was measured.
All other nematodes (M. incognita, R. reniformis, A. avenae, P. penetrans, and Helicotylenchus sp.) were fixed in Carnoy’s fixative for 2 h and then transferred to 50% methanol and stained with 0.2–0.5 μg/ml of DAPI overnight in the dark at room temperature until imaging. All images were captured with Zen software on a Zeiss M2 AxioImager with DIC and fluorescence optics and analyzed in FIJI. To examine the correlation between body volume and the number of epidermal nuclei among different nematode species, young adult females of M. incognita and R. reniformis, and J4 molting females of A. avenae, P. penetrans and Helicotylenchus sp. were examined. Nematode body shapes at these stages were considered to be cylindrical and the volume calculated as described for H. glycines. At least five animals were examined in each species. The data was log transformed. Regression analysis was performed using GraphPad Prism. Unlike Flemming et al. , we present the number of nuclei as the estimated total number rather than that found on one side of the body. We doubled the number of epidermal nuclei from Flemming et al.  to estimate the total number of nuclei in each species and reproduced the regression model based on their data. We mapped Tylenchomorpha nematode species on their regression model with 95% prediction intervals.
Nematodes were fixed in 4% paraformaldehyde overnight at 4 °C and washed three times with water. Nematodes were placed in a 3-mm Petri dish and cut open with a 1.2 mm × 25 mm BD precision glide needle (Becton, Dickinson, and Company). Nematodes were then transferred to phalloidin (5–7 unit/ml; Thermo Fisher Scientific) and DAPI (0.2–0.5 μg/ml; Thermo Fisher Scientific) and incubated overnight in the dark at room temperature. The images were taken using a confocal microscope (Zeiss LSM 880 Airyscan) and analyzed using ImageJ software.
Synchronized developmental stages of H. glycines were collected from soybean roots and stored overnight at 4 °C. High-pressure freezing and freeze substitution were modified from previous methods used for C. elegans [37, 38]. Metal specimen carriers were coated with 1-hexadecene and a layer of E. coli strain OP50. Nematodes were loaded into carriers with 20% bovine serum albumin and frozen in an HPM 010 high-pressure freezer. Freeze substitution was performed with 2% OsO4 (Electron Microscopy Sciences), 0.1% uranyl acetate (Polysciences), and 2% H2O in acetone in an FS-8500 freeze substitution system. Samples were kept at − 90 °C for 110 h before being warmed to − 20 °C over 5 h. Samples were then kept at − 20 °C for 16 h before being warmed to 0 °C over 5 h. Samples were washed four times in pre-chilled 100% acetone at 0 °C. The last wash was 1 h. Samples were then transferred to room temperature and washed two times in 100% acetone. Samples were infiltrated with 1:1 Polybed812 (Polysciences) resin/acetone for 24 h, 2:1 resin/acetone for 36 h, 100% resin for 24 h, and then changed to fresh resin for 3 days. All infiltration steps were conducted on an orbital shaker at room temperature. Samples were then submerged into embedding molds with resin and hardener and baked at 60 °C for 2 days. 70 nm sections were collected using a PowerTome PC ultramicrotome with a diamond knife and collected onto formvar-coated copper slot grids. Sections were stained with lead citrate and uranyl acetate and imaged with a Phillips CM200 TEM .
differential interference contrast
transmission electron microscopy
Schmidt GD. Tetrameres coloradensis sp. n., a nematode parasite of the common snipe Capella gallinago delicata. J Parasitol. 1962;48(6):850–1.
Adamson ML, Deets GB, Benz GW. Description of male and redescription of female Phlyctainophora squali Mudry and Dailey, 1969 (Nematoda; Dracunculoidea) from elasmobranchs. Can J Zool. 1987;65(12):3006–10.
Jones JT, Haegeman A, Danchin EG, Gaur HS, Helder J, Jones MG, Kikuchi T, Manzanilla-López R, Palomares-Rius JE, Wesemael WM, Perry RN. Top 10 plant-parasitic nematodes in molecular plant pathology. Mol Plant Pathol. 2013;14(9):946–61.
Bird AF. Growth and molting in nematodes: molting and development of the hatched larva of Rotylenchulus reniformis. Parasitology. 1984;89(1):107–20.
Holterman M, van der Wurff A, van den Elsen S, van Megen H, Bongers T, Holovachov O, Bakker J, Helder J. Phylum-wide analysis of SSU rDNA reveals deep phylogenetic relationships among nematodes and accelerated evolution toward crown clades. Mol Biol Evol. 2006;23(9):1792–800.
van Megen H, van den Elsen S, Holterman M, Karssen G, Mooyman P, Bongers T, Holovachov O, Bakker J, Helder J. A phylogenetic tree of nematodes based on about 1200 full-length small subunit ribosomal DNA sequences. Nematology. 2009;11(6):927–50.
Triantaphyllou AC, Hirschmann H. Post infection development of Meloidogyne incognita Chitwood 1949 (Nematoda-Heteroderidae). Annales de l’Institut Phytopathologique Benaki. 1960;1(3):1–11.
Flemming AJ, Shen ZZ, Cunha A, Emmons SW, Leroi AM. Somatic polyploidization and cellular proliferation drive body size evolution in nematodes. Proc Natl Acad Sci. 2000;97(10):5285–90.
Shemer G, Podbilewicz B. Fusomorphogenesis: cell fusion in organ formation. Dev Dyn. 2000;218(1):30–51.
Sulston JE, Horvitz HR. Post-embryonic cell lineages of the nematode, Caenorhabditis elegans. Dev Biol. 1977;56(1):110–56.
Singh RN, Sulston JE. Some observations on molting in Caenorhabditis elegans. Nematologica. 1978;24(1):63–71.
Azevedo RB, Cunha A, Emmons SW, Leroi AM. The demise of the platonic worm. Nematology. 2000;2(1):71–9.
Woodruff GC, Willis JH, Phillips PC. Dramatic evolution of body length due to postembryonic changes in cell size in a newly discovered close relative of Caenorhabditis elegans. Evol Lett. 2018;2(4):427–41.
Köppen M, Simske JS, Sims PA, Firestein BL, Hall DH, Radice AD, Rongo C, Hardin JD. Cooperative regulation of AJM-1 controls junctional integrity in Caenorhabditis elegans epithelia. Nat Cell Biol. 2001;3(11):983.
Podbilewicz B, White JG. Cell fusions in the developing epithelia of Caenorhabditis elegans. Developmental Biology. 1994;161(2):408–24.
Jay Burr AH, Baldwin JG. The nematode stoma: homology of cell architecture with improved understanding by confocal microscopy of labeled cell boundaries. J Morphol. 2016;277(9):1168–86.
Hedgecock EM, White JG. Polyploid tissues in the nematode Caenorhabditis elegans. Dev Biol. 1985;107(1):128–33.
Endo BY, Zunke U, Wergin WP. Ultrastructure of the lesion nematode, Pratylenchus penetrans (Nemata: Pratylenchidae). J Helminthol Soc Wash (USA). 1997;64(1):59–95.
Endo BY, Wergin WP. Ultrastructure of the second-stage juvenile of the root-knot nematode, Meloidogyne incognita. Proc Helminthol Soc Wash. 1988;55(2):286–316.
Sternberg PW, Horvitz HR. Postembryonic nongonadal cell lineages of the nematode Panagrellus redivivus: description and comparison with those of Caenorhabditis elegans. Dev Biol. 1982;93(1):181–205.
Cinkornpumin JK, Wisidagama DR, Rapoport V, Go JL, Dieterich C, Wang X, Sommer RJ, Hong RL. A host beetle pheromone regulates development and behavior in the nematode Pristionchus pacificus. eLife. 2014;3:e03229.
Noel GR, Stanger BA, Bloor PV. Population development, reproductive behavior, and morphology of race 4 of the soybean cyst nematode, Heterodera glycines, on resistant soybeans. Plant Dis. 1983;67(2):179–82.
Williams BD, Waterston RH. Genes critical for muscle development and function in Caenorhabditis elegans identified through lethal mutations. J Cell Biol. 1994;124(4):475–90.
Plunkett JA, Simmons RB, Walthall WW. Dynamic interactions between nerve and muscle in Caenorhabditis elegans. Dev Biol. 1996;175(1):154–65.
Han Z, Thapa S, Reuter-Carlson U, Reed H, Gates M, Lambert KN, Schroeder NE. Immobility in the sedentary plant-parasitic nematode Heterodera glycines is associated with remodeling of neuromuscular tissue. PLoS Pathog. 2018;14(8):e1007198.
Endo BY. Ultrastructure of cuticular exudates and related cuticular changes on juveniles in Heterodera glycines. J Helminthol Soc Wash (USA). 1993;60:76–88.
Robinson AF, Inserra RN, Caswell-Chen EP, Vovlas N, Troccoli A. Rotylenchulus species: identification, distribution, host ranges, and crop plant resistance. Nematropica. 1997;27(2):127–80.
Sipes BS, Schmitt DP, Barker KR. Fertility of three parasitic biotypes of Heterodera glycines. Phytopathology. 1992;82:999–1001.
Raski DJ. The life history and morphology of the sugar-beet nematode, Heterodera schachtii Schmidt. Phytopathology. 1950;40(2):135–52.
Wang C, Bruening G, Williamson VM. Determination of preferred pH for root-knot nematode aggregation using pluronic F-127 gel. J Chem Ecol. 2009;35(10):1242–51.
Dong L, Li X, Huang L, Gao Y, Zhong L, Zheng Y, Zuo Y. Lauric acid in crown daisy root exudate potently regulates root-knot nematode chemotaxis and disrupts Mi-flp-18 expression to block infection. J Exp Bot. 2013;65(1):131–41.
De Soyza K. Energetics of Aphelenchus avenae in monoxenic culture. Proceedings of the Helminthological Society of Washington. 1973;40:1.
Stiernagle T. Maintenance of C. elegans (February 11, 2006), WormBook, ed. The C. elegans Research Community, WormBook, doi/10.1895/wormbook. 1.101. 1.
Rebois RV, Huettel RN. Population dynamics, root penetration, and feeding behavior of Pratylenchus agilis in monoxenic root cultures of corn, tomato, and soybean. J Nematol. 1986;18(3):392.
Dunn RA. Extraction of eggs of Pratylenchus penetrans from alfalfa callus and relationship between age of culture and yield of eggs. J Nematol. 1973;5(1):73.
Fitzpatrick M. Measuring cell fluorescence using ImajeJ. 2014. https://theolb.readthedocs.io/en/latest/imaging/measuring-cell-fluorescence-using-imagej.html.
Hall DH, Hartwieg E, Nguyen KC. Modern electron microscopy methods for C. elegans. Methods Cell Biol. 2012;107:93–149.
Manning L, Richmond J. High-pressure freeze and freeze substitution electron microscopy in C. elegans. In: Biron D, Haspel G, editors. Methods in molecular biology. Berlin: Springer; 2015. p. 121–40.
ST and NES conceived the project and designed experiments. ST and MK conducted experiments. URC conducted TEM imaging. RJA conducted confocal imaging. ST and NES analyzed results. ST and NES wrote the paper. All authors read and approved the final manuscript.
ST and NES thank Dr. Jason Bond, Dr. Martin Wubben and Dr. Terry Niblack for providing nematodes; Dr. Carrie Butts-Wilmsmeyer for statistical advice; Scott Robinson and the Beckman Institute Imaging Technology Group for assistance with TEM; Dr. Lynn Carta for providing access to Dr. Burt Endo’s original TEM micrographs. ST would like to thank the Schlumberger Foundation, for a Faculty for the Future predoctoral fellowship.
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
Availability of data and materials
All data generated or analyzed during this study are included in this published article.
Consent for publications
Ethics approval and consent to participate
This research was supported by the Schlumberger Foundation C3560 (076510–02) to ST and NES, the USDA NIFA Hatch program (ILLU-802-934), and NIH NIGMS (R01GM111566) to NES.
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
About this article
Cite this article
Thapa, S., Gates, M.K., Reuter-Carlson, U. et al. Convergent evolution of saccate body shapes in nematodes through distinct developmental mechanisms. EvoDevo 10, 5 (2019). https://doi.org/10.1186/s13227-019-0118-5
- Soybean cyst nematode
- Root-knot nematode
- Reniform nematode
- Lesion nematode